At a recent Men’s Long Table someone raised the vexed issue of ’boat-people’ and how we are to respond as Christians. The passionate discussion that followed revealed a real struggle within each of us to respect the laws of the land and show compassion – the tension between being generous and just. It also revealed how hard it is to understand where others come from and why they take such risks.
A number of years ago I knew a student minister who drove a taxi part-time in order to pay the bills. He used to end his shift and hand over at 3am to a tiny Cambodian fellow. One night he asked him what he did when he’d get a taxi full of big, drunk Aussies giving him a hard time. The Cambodian man just laughed: “You guys have no idea what ‘a hard time’ is.” It turned out this man had had his entire family shot by the Khmer-Rouge before his eyes. He had fled and, somehow, made his way to Australia. He found this country to be a ‘strange oasis’ of peace and order, but also (and perhaps mercifully) ignorant of what was going on in neighbouring parts of the world.
I often think of that man when I see the footage of the boats towed in to Christmas Island and the faces of those sitting cross-legged on the deck. Where are you from? What has driven you away from home and out onto the water?
I know there are thousands who have waited in line, waded through the interminable beauracracy, and arrived according to the law. I know two Iraqi Christians in particular who came this way, then laboured long to help their family flee the warzone and come out by the right channels. I know it is a godly thing to respect the laws of the land (1 Peter2:13-17) and that illegal immigration draws precious resources away from an already stretched department. I know there will inevitably be those whose refusal to wait for official channels will also be reflected in dishonest dealings with the govenment once here (a long Australian tradition, I might add!). Letting others in before those who’ve applied and waited is not fair.
And yet, I look at those faces and wonder. What if ‘official channels’ in their country have meant terror, violence and loss? What if they have never known a day when they could trust the authorities or have a voice in politics? If I found myself, Michelle and the kids in the rubble of Afghanistan or Cairo’s ‘city of the dead’, wouldn’t I do all I could to get us out?
I look at those faces and wonder about Jesus’ command to be merciful (Luke 6:36) and that vital fruit of his Spirit within us: compassion (Galatians 5:22,23). This is a readiness to look on the brokenness of another and not walk away or slam the door. It means loving and serving, as Jesus has loved and served us, well beyond any worldy guage of ‘fairness’. Grace isnt fair or even. It’s costly and utterly of God. In Jesus, crucified and risen for us, we see that tension between being generous and just played out in full.
How this works through a secular government or any of the agencies working in this area, I do not know. There are so many tensions in this matter and I suspect last Tuesday’s Long table will not be the last word spoken on the matter. Yet I know this. I would rather live in a country that shows costly compassion to that Cambodian man, than a nation that slams the door on all because some abuse that grace.
I want to live amongst people who keep asking: Where are you from? What has driven you from your home and out onto the water?
I’ll leave the last word to Bruce Smith
BOAT PEOPLE
Torn from
their moorings
by tempestuous events,
cast upon open seas
hoping for
distant kindness.
Crowded undernourished
ill-equipped
they float
under God’s eye
menaced by fears.
They drift
in the
shoreless conscience
of our world.
Their frail light
flickers
in ocean’s night.